个案概念化的定义、理论,AI的个案概念化的能力与测量
个案概念化的定义、核心框架与治疗性作用(总论性教材与述评)
这组文献属于个案概念化的总体性、导论性论述:教材(psychotherapy_case_formulation_2nd_ed)、当代心理治疗中的概念化综述(case_formulation_in_contemporary_psychotherapy)、概念化在治疗中的角色定位(the_role_of_case_formulation_in)以及相关章节评论(commentary_to_chapter_case_formulation_as),共同界定个案概念化的定义、功能与构成要素,为后续取向分化与实证测量提供概念基础。
- Psychotherapy case formulation (2nd ed.).(T. Eells, 2026, No journal)
- Case Formulation in Contemporary Psychotherapy(R. Mendelsohn, 2023, No journal)
- The role of case formulation in the current practice of psychotherapy(T. Eells, 2025, World Psychiatry)
- Commentary to Chapter “Case Formulation as an Outcome and Not an Opening Move in Relational and Psychodynamic Models”: Plan Formulation Vs. Case Formulation: The Perspective of Control-Mastery Theory(F. Gazzillo, George Silberschatz, 2021, No journal)
单一治疗取向下的个案概念化模型:心理动力学、人本主义与认知行为取向
这组文献分别聚焦于某一具体理论流派的个案概念化模型与操作范式:心理动力学(case_formulation_in_psychoanalysis_and_in、la_formulacin_psicodinmica_de_caso_su)、人本主义各分支(diagnosis_and_case_formulation_in_humanistic)以及认知行为治疗的循证实践(evidence_based_practices_in_cognitive_behaviour_therapy),体现概念化在取向内部的理论根基与流派特异性。
- Case Formulation in Psychoanalysis and in Cognitive-Behavioral Therapies: Commentary on Chapter “Case Formulation as an Outcome and Not an Opening Move in Relational and Psychodynamic Models”(P. Migone, 2021, No journal)
- La formulación psicodinámica de caso. Su valor para la práctica clínica [Psychodynamic case formulation: Its value for clinical practice]*(Andrea Rodríguez Quiroga, 2018, The International Journal of Psychoanalysis)
- Diagnosis and Case Formulation in Humanistic Psychotherapies(Felipe Concha, José Blanco-Machinea, Ueli Kramer, 2026, Journal of humanistic psychology)
- Evidence-based practices in cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) case formulation: what do practitioners believe is important, and what do they do?(P. Huisman, M. Kangas, 2018, Behaviour Change)
整合性、跨诊断与过程取向的个案概念化理论拓展
这组文献超越单一流派,探讨概念化的整合与跨诊断路径:心理动力学与CBT理论技能的整合(psychodynamic_and_cognitive_behavioral_theory_and)、基于过程的跨诊断模块化概念化(case_conceptualization_from_a_process_based_and)、以进化与主体间原则构建共同语言的进化个案概念化及其批判性评述(beyond_integration_a_critical_analysis_of)、社会情境中的整合概念化(an_integrated_case_formulation_in_social),共同反映概念化理论由流派分化走向整合与机制导向的发展趋势。
- Psychodynamic and Cognitive Behavioral Theory and Practice(Terry B. Northcut, Shveta Kumaria, 2025, No journal)
- Case conceptualization from a process-based and modular perspective: Rationale and application to mood and anxiety disorders.(P. Philippot, M. Bouvard, C. Baeyens, V. Dethier, 2018, Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy)
- Beyond Integration: A Critical Analysis of Quiñones’ Evolutionary Case Formulation Model (ECF)(Luis Botella García del Cid, 2026, Revista de Psicoterapia)
- An Integrated Case Formulation in Social Work: Toward Developing a Theory of a Client(Eunjung Lee, Henry Toth, 2016, Smith College Studies in Social Work)
个案概念化在临床干预中的应用:个体化治疗设计、治疗联盟与改变机制
这组文献关注概念化如何具体驱动临床实践:以概念化定制CPT以改善PTSD功能结局的随机对照试验(personalizing_cognitive_processing_therapy_with_a)、创伤个案概念化工具的开发(development_of_a_trauma_case_formulation)、人格障碍治疗中分阶段概念化与改变机制的监测(clinical_diagnosis_and_case_formulation_in)、处理治疗中的矛盾心理(how_to_deal_with_ambivalence_in)、概念化与治疗关系的作用(case_formulation_and_the_therapeutic_relationship)以及治疗师的概念化与治疗观念(case_formulation_and_treatment_concepts_among),体现概念化作为治疗计划、联盟建构与进程评估中介的实践价值。
- Personalizing cognitive processing therapy with a case formulation approach to intentionally target impairment in psychosocial functioning associated with PTSD(T. Galovski, L. McSweeney, R. Nixon, J. S. Wachen, B. N. Smith, S. Noorbaloochi, D. Vogt, B. Niles, S. Kehle-Forbes, 2024, Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications)
- Development of a trauma case formulation framework(TCFF): The case formulation approach for trauma-focused psychotherapy(Hyesun Joo, 2016, THE KOREAN JOURNAL OF COUNSELING AND PSYCHOTHERAPY)
- Clinical diagnosis and case formulation in the psychotherapy of personality disorders(L. Cierpiałkowska, 2023, Advances in Psychiatry and Neurology)
- How to Deal with Ambivalence in Psychotherapy: A Conceptual Model for Case Formulation(J. T. Oliveira, Miguel M. Gonçalves, Cátia Braga, António P. Ribeiro, 2016, No journal)
- Case Formulation and the Therapeutic Relationship from an Evolutionary Theory of Motivation: Commentary to Chapter “Strengths and Limitations of Case Formulation in Constructivist Cognitive Behavioral Therapies”(F. Monticelli, 2021, No journal)
- Case Formulation and Treatment Concepts Among Novice, Experienced, and Expert Cognitive-Behavioral and Psychodynamic Therapists(T. Eells, Kenneth G. Lombart, 2003, Psychotherapy Research)
个案概念化的能力评估与量化测量方法
这组文献聚焦概念化的可测量性问题:面向BPD心理动力治疗的概念化胜任力量表编制与内容效度检验(psychometric_properties_of_comprehensive_cognitive_affective)、以理论引导的个体化网络模型量化个案概念化并识别亚型(quantifying_clinical_case_formulation_person_specific_dynamic)、以及支撑质性/概念化编码与整合的概念框架(the_conceptual_framework_of_thematic_mapping),为概念化的信效度、个体化测量与结构化表征提供方法学基础。
- Psychometric properties of comprehensive cognitive, affective, and psychomotor competency assessment scales in psychodynamic psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder(P. R. Lukman, T. Wiguna, D. Soemantri, S. Menaldi, S. D. Elvira, Limas Sutanto, T. W. A. Sapiie, A. Kekalih, Reina Rahma Noviasari, Hukma Shabiyya Rizki, Kharisma Zatalini Giyani, 2024, Frontiers in Psychiatry)
- Quantifying Clinical Case Formulation: Person-Specific Dynamic Network Modelling of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).(N. Hertz-Palmor, Alicja Podgorski, Gary P. Brown, Amit Lazarov, J. Porat, Shany Edelman Yaron, Anna Bevan, T. Dalgleish, 2026, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics)
- The Conceptual Framework of Thematic Mapping in Case Conceptualization.(Charles R. Ridley, Christina E. Jeffrey, 2017, Journal of Clinical Psychology)
人工智能与自然语言处理在个案概念化中的应用能力与评测
这组文献直接对应AI开展个案概念化的能力与测量主题: counselling/心理治疗领域NLP应用的范畴综述(scoping_review_on_natural_language_processing)呈现自动化编码、结局预测、会谈监测与语言模式分析的技术路径及其偏差与泛化性局限;大语言模型辅助新手咨询师进行个案概念化的效果评估(enhancing_case_formulation_competence_in_novice)则以督导评分检验AI对概念化全面性与连贯性的提升及在复杂性与特异性上的不足。
- Scoping review on natural language processing applications in counselling and psychotherapy(M. Laricheva, Yan Liu, Edward Shi, Amery D. Wu, 2024, British Journal of Psychology)
- Enhancing Case Formulation Competence in Novice Counselors: A ChatGPT-Assisted Approach Using the 4P Model(Yan-Shan Dai, Han Han, Yong-Ze Xu, 2026, Behavioral Science)
本组文献围绕"个案概念化的定义、理论与AI个案概念化能力及测量"形成由总到分、由理论到实证的逻辑链条:首先以教材与总论性述评界定个案概念化的定义、构成要素与治疗性作用;继而按治疗取向分述心理动力学、人本主义与认知行为流派的概念化模型,并进一步呈现整合性、跨诊断与过程取向的理论拓展;随后转向临床应用层面,考察概念化如何驱动个体化治疗设计、治疗联盟与改变机制的监测;在方法学层面,聚焦概念化胜任力量表编制、理论引导的个体化网络量化以及概念框架的结构化表征,回应其信效度与可测量性;最后落到AI与NLP技术,既有范畴综述梳理自动化编码与结局预测等技术路径及偏差与泛化性局限,也有以督导评分检验大语言模型提升新手概念化全面性与连贯性的实证研究,从而将"AI的个案概念化能力如何界定与测量"置于前述理论与测量传统之中加以评估。
这组文献属于个案概念化的总体性、导论性论述:教材(psychotherapy_case_formulation_2nd_ed)、当代心理治疗中的概念化综述(case_formulation_in_contemporary_psychotherapy)、概念化在治疗中的角色定位(the_role_of_case_formulation_in)以及相关章节评论(commentary_to_chapter_case_formulation_as),共同界定个案概念化的定义、功能与构成要素,为后续取向分化与实证测量提供概念基础。相关文献:T. Eells et. al, 2026 等 4 篇文献
这组文献分别聚焦于某一具体理论流派的个案概念化模型与操作范式:心理动力学(case_formulation_in_psychoanalysis_and_in、la_formulacin_psicodinmica_de_caso_su)、人本主义各分支(diagnosis_and_case_formulation_in_humanistic)以及认知行为治疗的循证实践(evidence_based_practices_in_cognitive_behaviour_therapy),体现概念化在取向内部的理论根基与流派特异性。相关文献:P. Migone et. al, 2021 等 4 篇文献
这组文献超越单一流派,探讨概念化的整合与跨诊断路径:心理动力学与CBT理论技能的整合(psychodynamic_and_cognitive_behavioral_theory_and)、基于过程的跨诊断模块化概念化(case_conceptualization_from_a_process_based_and)、以进化与主体间原则构建共同语言的进化个案概念化及其批判性评述(beyond_integration_a_critical_analysis_of)、社会情境中的整合概念化(an_integrated_case_formulation_in_social),共同反映概念化理论由流派分化走向整合与机制导向的发展趋势。相关文献:Terry B. Northcut et. al, 2025 等 4 篇文献
这组文献关注概念化如何具体驱动临床实践:以概念化定制CPT以改善PTSD功能结局的随机对照试验(personalizing_cognitive_processing_therapy_with_a)、创伤个案概念化工具的开发(development_of_a_trauma_case_formulation)、人格障碍治疗中分阶段概念化与改变机制的监测(clinical_diagnosis_and_case_formulation_in)、处理治疗中的矛盾心理(how_to_deal_with_ambivalence_in)、概念化与治疗关系的作用(case_formulation_and_the_therapeutic_relationship)以及治疗师的概念化与治疗观念(case_formulation_and_treatment_concepts_among),体现概念化作为治疗计划、联盟建构与进程评估中介的实践价值。相关文献:T. Galovski et. al, 2024 等 6 篇文献
这组文献聚焦概念化的可测量性问题:面向BPD心理动力治疗的概念化胜任力量表编制与内容效度检验(psychometric_properties_of_comprehensive_cognitive_affective)、以理论引导的个体化网络模型量化个案概念化并识别亚型(quantifying_clinical_case_formulation_person_specific_dynamic)、以及支撑质性/概念化编码与整合的概念框架(the_conceptual_framework_of_thematic_mapping),为概念化的信效度、个体化测量与结构化表征提供方法学基础。相关文献:P. R. Lukman et. al, 2024 等 3 篇文献
这组文献直接对应AI开展个案概念化的能力与测量主题: counselling/心理治疗领域NLP应用的范畴综述(scoping_review_on_natural_language_processing)呈现自动化编码、结局预测、会谈监测与语言模式分析的技术路径及其偏差与泛化性局限;大语言模型辅助新手咨询师进行个案概念化的效果评估(enhancing_case_formulation_competence_in_novice)则以督导评分检验AI对概念化全面性与连贯性的提升及在复杂性与特异性上的不足。相关文献:M. Laricheva et. al, 2024 等 2 篇文献
总计 23 篇相关文献
This article presents the theoretical, clinical, and practical arguments supporting a process-based transdiagnostic approach to psychotherapy. A working definition of "psychological process" is provided, as well as a tri-dimensional categorization of psychological processes potentially involved in psychopathology. Guidelines are proposed to select psychological interventions based on the active psychopathological processes evidenced in a given case. We also provide a rationale to organize treatment as a set of modules, each addressing a specific psychopathological process. Next, we review the main processes that may be active in mood and anxiety disorders, and that are accessible to clinicians in regular practice. For each process, we propose a validated assessment questionnaire. Finally, we offer a free-access web-based instrument that allows clients to fill in these questionnaires via an internet survey, and that provides therapists with a tool to easily decode and interpret the questionnaire results and to present them to the clients.
No abstract available
No abstract available
No abstract available
Psychodynamic theory and cognitive behavioral interventions are two theoretical frameworks and methods of intervention that have consistently been found to have therapeutic value, albeit with different symptoms and/or presenting problems. It is critical to combine these two frameworks with an ongoing focus on the impact on the client when and how these shifts occur in treatment. Both theories are examined within a historical and contextual lens combined with contributions from interpersonal neurobiology and psychotherapy research. This book considers the skills of reflexivity, attunement, and resonance, which build on a strong psychodynamic relational frame and provides a bridge to cognitive behavioral theory and techniques. Case illustrations demonstrate the importance of understanding clients within a social justice and relational perspective that draws on established strengths of both frameworks and supports, thoughtful, thorough case formulations that can adapt to client needs, values, and symptoms.
No abstract available
No abstract available
BACKGROUND Psychopathology research typically relies on nomothetic (group-level) data to infer idiographic (person-level) processes, limiting clinical relevance and failing to capture complex individual presentations. Conversely, idiographic approaches capture within-person dynamics but often lack theoretical structure to support generalisation, creating a nomothetic-idiographic gap. This study addresses this gap by operationalising Ehlers and Clark's (E&C) Cognitive Model of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) within a theory-guided idiographic network framework. METHOD Study 1 used simulations to establish data requirements for reliably testing model-derived hypotheses. Study 2 applied this framework to intensive longitudinal data from trauma-exposed individuals. Fifty-five participants (31 with PTSD, 24 with clinical-level symptoms) selected personalised items reflecting core model components: negative appraisals, trauma memory, triggers, sense of current threat, and maladaptive strategies. A subsample of 41 participants completed 3 weeks of Ecological Momentary Assessment, yielding 2,594 observations (M=63.2 per participant). Individualised items were mapped onto shared theoretical constructs and analysed using complementary network models. RESULTS Findings provided empirical support for key assumptions of the E&C model, particularly the central role of sense of current threat and its associations with trauma memory, negative appraisals, triggers, and maladaptive strategies. Clustering of individual networks identified four recurring formulation subtypes characterised by threat reactivity, appraisal centrality, memory centrality, or trigger-threat association. CONCLUSIONS We demonstrate a method for bridging individualised assessment with theory-driven analysis. By combining personalised data collection with a shared mechanistic framework, idiographic networks can extend beyond single-case descriptions to identify common clinical patterns, with potential implications for formulation, intervention planning, and evaluation.
No abstract available
No abstract available
No abstract available
Background Psychodynamic psychotherapy is a type of psychotherapy for individuals with borderline personality disorder (BPD). However, competency in conducting effective psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD is difficult to evaluate. Therefore, this study aimed to identify the psychometric properties of a comprehensive scale to assess cognitive, affective, and psychomotor competencies (CS-CAPC) in psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD. Methods This is a qualitative study. The first step used the Delphi technique to gather experts’ opinions on the cognitive, affective, and psychomotor competencies necessary to conduct psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD. The experts comprised three psychotherapists, seven psychiatrists with experience in psychotherapy, and nine teaching staff. A panel discussion was conducted to obtain qualitative data. Thematic data analysis was adopted, and content validity testing was used to analyze the content validity of the CS-CAPC in psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD. Results The CS-CAPC comprised two scales assessing two specific competencies in psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD: The first scale, the psychodynamic formulation competency assessment scale (PF-CAS), comprised six items, including the case description, etiology, and potential course of therapy. The second scale, the practical-competency assessment scale (PC-CAS) for psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD, comprised 12 items, including building a therapeutic alliance, performing psychodynamic interventions while working through the therapeutic process, and closing the session. The scale-level content validity index (S-CVI) for the PF-CAS was 0.981, and that for the PC-CAS in psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD was 1.00. Conclusion The CS-CAPC in psychodynamic psychotherapy for BPD had good validity in assessing individual competency in the cognitive, affective, and psychomotor domains.
No abstract available
No abstract available
Purpose The article aimed to present a case conceptualization in two stages of therapy for PD patients qualifying for a specific therapy modality and diagnosis, including the conceptualization and monitoring of the process and mechanism of changes under the influence of specific therapeutic interventions. The problem is significant as there is a high level of treatment dropout among patients with various personality disorders. Views The article discusses the current state of knowledge and Kazdin’s methodology of scientific research on the processes and mechanisms of change in patients under the influence of therapeutic interventions. Using the assumptions of this model, the author describes the six steps of a therapeutic procedure which aims at describing and monitoring the process and mechanism of therapeutic interventions, with a special emphasis on the significance of a mediator in the form of the therapeutic alliance. The therapeutic alliance is a significant mediator of changes leading to positive and/or negative therapy outcome and some of its components should be considered as moderators that may significantly modify the influence of the mediator on the strength of the links between a given therapy modality and its effectiveness. Conclusions Kazdin’s model and diagnostic principles seem very useful and promising in clinical practice. At our current stage of knowledge and research, the diagnosing and monitoring of the process and mechanism of change in patients, resulting from specific therapeutic interventions, constitutes a considerable challenge for psychotherapists and clinicians.
No abstract available
With the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technology, various scientific research fields are exploring the application of potential of new technologies. Counseling psychology, closely intertwined with natural language processing, is one of the most suitable domains for such exploration. This study focuses on investigating the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in assisting novice counselors with case-formulation processes. Based on supervisors’ ratings of novice counselors’ performance before and after using LLMs, the results indicate that AI assistance significantly enhances the comprehensiveness and coherence of case formulation, while its effects on complexity and specificity are not statistically significant. Additionally, through novice counselors’ subjective evaluations of the AI-assisted process, the value of AI tools in broadening perspectives and facilitating convenient operations is identified. Overall, the findings suggest that AI can moderately assist novice counselors in understanding clients. However, to better integrate AI with professional practice and improve case formulation competence, it is essential for novice counselors to maintain critical thinking and strengthen their learning of counseling theories and techniques during AI application.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a debilitating condition often accompanied by significant functional impairments affecting quality of life and well-being. While Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) is a leading, evidence-based psychotherapy for PTSD, demonstrating substantial efficacy in core symptom reduction, its impact on psychosocial functioning is less well-established. The Personalizing Cognitive Processing Therapy with a Case Formulation Approach (Personalizing Approaches to Therapy: PATh) study aims to enhance CPT by explicitly targeting functional impairments and idiosyncratic challenges to optimal therapy outcomes (COTOs), comparing its efficacy against standard CPT in improving psychosocial functioning, quality of life, well-being, and core PTSD and depression symptoms. This randomized controlled trial involves 200 Veterans across eight Veterans Health Administration clinical sites, assigned to either Case Formulation CPT (CF-CPT) or standard CPT. Providers will deliver up to 20 sessions per patient, with assessments at baseline, mid-treatment, post-treatment, and three months follow-up. It is hypothesized that Veterans receiving CF-CPT will show greater improvements in functioning, quality of life, well-being, and symptom reduction, alongside higher treatment completion rates compared to standard CPT. Secondary outcomes will examine specific clinical challenges and their influence on treatment outcomes. This study investigates whether a personalized, flexible CPT protocol can enhance functional recovery in PTSD treatment without compromising the efficacy of the traditional approach, potentially impacting clinical practices and patient outcomes by promoting holistic recovery for veterans with PTSD.
Este artículo presenta una revisión crítica de Evolutionary Case Formulation: Developing a Unified Language for the Practice of Psychotherapy, de Álvaro Quiñones. El libro propone un modelo de formulación de casos basado en principios evolutivos e intersubjetivos que busca ofrecer un lenguaje común para integrar distintas orientaciones psicoterapéuticas. Se destacan como principales fortalezas su solidez conceptual, su énfasis en la construcción compartida de significados y su equilibrio entre estructura y flexibilidad. Desde una perspectiva constructivista, se analizan sus afinidades con la Psicología de los Constructos Personales, la terapia narrativa y otros enfoques centrados en el significado. Asimismo, se explora su posible integración con los Mapas Cognitivos Borrosos como herramienta para la personalización de la psicoterapia. En conjunto, la obra constituye una aportación original y valiosa al desarrollo de modelos integradores, idiográficos y dinámicos de formulación clínica.
The present article examines the role of diagnosis and case formulation in humanistic psychotherapies. The diversity of approaches within the humanistic paradigm is addressed, including person-centered therapy, gestalt therapy, existential therapy, and emotion-focused therapy. Additionally, specific case formulation models developed within these traditions are explored, providing examples of generic and integrative case formulation proposals and specific models from numerous humanistic schools. Furthermore, methods of case formulation specifically developed for research in humanistic psychotherapy are presented, including the hermeneutic single-case efficacy design method and multiple-case depth research method. The article concludes by emphasizing the commitment of humanistic psychotherapies to research and ethical standards, highlighting the need to critically evaluate the effectiveness and relevance of diagnosis and case formulation processes.
No abstract available
No abstract available
Abstract Recent years have witnessed some rapid and tremendous progress in natural language processing (NLP) techniques that are used to analyse text data. This study endeavours to offer an up‐to‐date review of NLP applications by examining their use in counselling and psychotherapy from 1990 to 2021. The purpose of this scoping review is to identify trends, advancements, challenges and limitations of these applications. Among the 41 papers included in this review, 4 primary study purposes were identified: (1) developing automated coding; (2) predicting outcomes; (3) monitoring counselling sessions; and (4) investigating language patterns. Our findings showed a growing trend in the number of papers utilizing advanced machine learning methods, particularly neural networks. Unfortunately, only a third of the articles addressed the issues of bias and generalizability. Our findings provided a timely systematic update, shedding light on concerns related to bias, generalizability and validity in the context of NLP applications in counselling and psychotherapy.